moblog uk

view from my pocket

by mat

user profile | dashboard | imagewall | contact user

« older newer »

Buy my stuff! - modernist wooden jewellery, award-winning computer accessories and more.

Flow Food - my flowchart recipe blog

"Do you realise that every blade of grass is a different shade of green?" - from My Voice Will Go With You

Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike License

Search this moblog

Recent visitors


(viewed 968 times)
Bookmark and Share
4th May 2005, 22:26   | tags:

eversion says:

Ah come on, it was alright. The petunias glancing off the windscreen was particularly satisfying.

4th May 2005, 22:32

crickson says:

I enjoyed it. Ok, so it wont be remembered come oscar time, but it made me laugh and entertained me for a couple of hours.

4th May 2005, 22:48

kostika says:

I won't be going to see it. I've heard enough things about it that I don't want to spend money to see it.

5th May 2005, 09:38

crickson says:

Give it a chance, honestly, it's a laugh.

5th May 2005, 10:20

kostika says:

I'll probably download it to watch. I really don't wanna spend money on it cause it doesn't sound like i'll like it.

5th May 2005, 11:18

Rich says:

Well I liked it, given that it's a pretty impossible thing to turn into a film they gave it as good a stab as could be expected. Zaphod was good, Trillian has joined the massed ranks of my future wives, the special effects were effective and Mos Def wasn't totally awful. It really made me wish that they'd remade the TV series with those production values, though. That would have rocked nads.

5th May 2005, 13:09

kostika says:

Its not the changes that worry me. A majority of the story is DA's screenplay. What worries me, and I've not heard good things about, is the delivery. I've seen the tv series and i loved it. In my mind, that's what it has to live up to and from what I've heard, it hasn't even come close.

5th May 2005, 13:15

Rich says:

Mmm, well, I guess if you want to base your opinions on what other people think then that's your right, personally I always want to make up my own mind on these matters.

5th May 2005, 16:59

kostika says:

Normally I wouldn't. But I asked trusted friends who's opinions I trust on this one cause I've been a bit dubious about it for a while now.

5th May 2005, 17:02

Rich says:

Even still, when all that's at stake is, what, five pounds and 90 minutes of your life? And you get to see a pretty good reimagining of an old favorite as well? Does not compute.

Evidence for: New Zaphod is good. Old Zaphod, on the whole, is pretty shit, and not just the head. New Trillian is infinitely less irritating than Sandra Dickinson, OK so Ford isn't so great, but he does kinda work, Martin Freeman makes a good Arthur, the interior of the Heart of Gold is fantastic, and most of the jokes are pretty good, and the delivery was fine from where I was sitting. Of course you don't know or trust me so it'll count for nothing, I just think it's worth a chance is all. Plus you'll be giving money to Douglas's family, which is almost certainly what he would have wanted. If I'm a fan of something I always want to support them with my hard earned readies rather than pirate it, it's only fair.

5th May 2005, 17:18

kostika says:

Well ya see if I like it, I'll buy it. If I don't, I won't feel like I've wasted my money. If I like it I may even go see it in the cinema.

It wouldn't be jsut 5 pounds. It'd be 10 for the movie (hubby and me) plus another 10 for getting to Basingstoke (I live in a village) to see it. Plus likely another 10 for food cause we'll likely be hungry.

If I don't like it, I won't keep the file anyhow.

5th May 2005, 17:27

Rich says:

Ahhh, well, that's OK then, my righteous ire has been extinguished ;D

5th May 2005, 18:37

kostika says:

I'm glad I could apease the angry Rich god. Thank you almighty one for your forgiveness


6th May 2005, 09:03

ladislav says:

I think Mos Def was better than the TV Ford (though less good than the radio one). Simon Jones was a better Arthur than Martin Freeman, but both are good. Zaphod in the film was better than Zaphod in the TV series, but less good than the radio show (odd, as the last two were both Mark Wing-Davey). Overall, I think the film was pretty good, but it had been Disnefied and lost some of the cynicism that was its hallmark. Ah well. There will undoubtedly be sequels...

6th May 2005, 21:34

kitkat says:

Whoever played Trillian was rubbish apart from that i didnt think it was that bad - what do you expect from a movie of the DA books you just cant translate that to screen - Anyhow if your a DA fan you might want to look at "his" playlist on the iTunes store - Or not ....

See you around

11th May 2005, 17:55

alfie says:

I like how Mat hasnt actually come back to expound on his two word capsule review - not really like him, so he mustve really disliked it to not even say why.

11th May 2005, 18:17

mat says:

finally back online, can update this:

Marvin = excellent (original Marvin cameo - inspired)
HoG = excellent
Slartibartfast = excellent
Tribute to the simpsons with the rake/face/slapping joke = excellent
Petunias = excellent
Vogons = excellent
Stephen Fry = excellent, but under-used.
Magrathean workshop floor = stunning.

Ford, Zaphod = not Cool. They're supposed to be Cool, in not necessarily likeable. They were just annoying.
Ford = just not funny. MosDef might be a good actor, but he doesn't have the comic timing required for this part. Also, the jokes aren't as funny in an American accent. (same goes for Zaphod.) Apologies to the the US contingent here, it's nothing personal :)
Love Interest? With actual resolution and everything? Please.
Insertion of stock Hollywood plotline and Happy Ending(TM) = enough to make me nearly walk out in disgust. I hate hollywood endings.
Trillian = annoying.

The worst thing? The absolute worst thing? The fact that, as Stephen Fry said "the words 'Don't Panic' printed in large reassuring letters on the front", the book span to show that it was actually printed on the back.. :)

11th May 2005, 18:21

seaneeboy says:

I have just had to endure "The Wedding Date"

I feel like i've had my brain raped by a horse.

11th May 2005, 20:01

Helen says:

I thought he said that the words "Don't Panic" were printed "on the cover", which puzzled me a bit.. but then I just theorised that the back of the book is actually part of the cover (and chastised myself for not automatically knowing/thinking this).

It was alright, made me laugh. Not a screen play I would envy being in charge of. Might have changed the cast a bit...

11th May 2005, 21:07

neel says:

I'm not going to comment. I've thought about writing out a neel review, but there are some things that are, y'know, personal. HHGttG is one such thing.

[ neel shuts up ]

11th May 2005, 21:17

mat says:

Helen: yeah, you're totally right. I'm indignant though, you can't stop me with mere facts...

11th May 2005, 21:17

Joe says:

"Not a screen play I would envy being in charge of. Might have changed the cast a bit..."
*THIS* is why I haven't been to see it....despite being possibly the worlds biggest 'guide geek known to man.

11th May 2005, 21:18

Helen says:

Facts are overrated.

Being right is not.

Hmmm I suppose that is a point about this version, it didn't feel too personal, it didn't feel like it belonged to anyone... quite like that... it wasn't particularly British, or even particularly Douglas... it's sort of distanced and diffused. Who does this movie belong to?

11th May 2005, 21:23

neel says:

Joe: them's fightin' words!

11th May 2005, 21:41

Add a comment

(P) what's this?

Track updates to this post with rssthis rss feed